Professor of Child and Youth Studies and Canada Research Chair Danielle Sirianni Molnar led a recent study examining the traits and life circumstances of young adults in the U.S. who call themselves perfectionists.It’s a label people casually toss around in conversations about school, work and life in general: “perfectionist.” But do young adults who call themselves perfectionists exhibit the behaviours and psychological traits associated with perfectionism?
A Brock University-led study says yes — and reveals who is willing to say it out loud may depend on identity and background as much as on perfectionism itself.
Unlike her team’s earlier study, Danielle Sirianni Molnar (BA ’01, MA ’05, PhD ’11), Professor of Child and Youth Studies and Canada Research Chair in Adjustment and Well-Being in Children and Youth, says perfectionists were not specifically recruited to participate in their latest project.
“We wanted to know if young adults gave themselves that label because it’s generally a desired characteristic in the broader world, like the cliché of perfectionism disguised as a ‘weakness’ in a job interview when it’s actually perceived as signs of competence and high achievement,” she says.
A second aim of the study was to determine if social identities — gender, sexual orientation, race or socio-economic status — are related to validated measures of perfectionism.
Data were collected from 988 participants aged 18 to 25 in the U.S. in a way designed to reflect the country’s population benchmarks across key demographic characteristics. Participants were asked if they consider themselves perfectionists and answered questions derived from three psychological scales containing validated measures of perfectionism.
One scale measured the perfectionism traits of concern over mistakes, setting high personal standards, parental expectations, experiences of parental criticism, doubts about actions and being organized.
Another scale explored self-oriented perfectionism, which is the tendency to set and pursue excessively high and rigid personal standards; other-oriented perfectionism, which is demanding perfection from others; and socially prescribed perfectionism, which is the belief that others require perfection, resulting in high levels of self-criticism.
A third scale distinguished between perfectionism — which the study described as the tendency to relentlessly strive toward idealized, flawless and excessively high standards — and “excellencism,” described as the tendency to aim for very high yet attainable standards in a determined but flexible way.
Key findings:
- Young adults who said they were perfectionists scored high on every measure in each of the three scales, indicating they accurately discerned their perfectionism according to validated measures.
- Women were more likely than men to endorse the perfectionist label.
- 2SLGBTQIA+ participants were more likely to self-identify as perfectionists compared to their heterosexual peers.
- People from lower socio-economic backgrounds showed a stronger connection between identifying as a perfectionist and scoring higher on measures of perfectionism.
These and other findings were published in the study, “Validating self-identified perfectionism as an indicator of trait perfectionism and examining differences across key demographic characteristics,” in Current Psychologyin September.
The team includes Brock Professor of Child and Youth Studies Dawn Zinga, Child and Youth Studies PhD student Melissa Blackburn, Psychology PhD student Hanna Puffer, Paul Hewitt from the University of British Columbia and Gordon Flett from York University. Funding for the study was provided by the Canada Research Chairs Program.
Sirianni Molnar says the U.S. study will be followed up with a similar, longer-term study in Canada that looks at the development of perfectionism over time.
“Canada’s unique educational and social landscapes may contribute to how young people experience pressure, and following young adults over time lets us see how perfectionism unfolds through real-life transitions,” she says. “We’re also broadening our language beyond the label ‘perfectionist’ to include those who strive for perfection but may not identify with the term.”
The research team is recruiting Canadians aged 18 to 30 who are fluent in English to participate in the upcoming study, which involves completing three 50-minute online surveys at six-month intervals. Those interested in participating can contact [email protected]